In this IJURR debate, three critical urban scholars (Vinay Gidwani, Alana Boland and Roger Keil) and one water scholar (Farhana Sultana), who have done field research in different parts of the world, discuss and analyze different aspects of Karen Bakker’s contributions to the question of water access in urban areas of the global South. Karen Bakker has the final word.

Full debate can be found here.